The New Criterion

It operates as a refuge for a civilizing element in short supply in contemporary America: honest criticism
- The Wall Street Journal

Letters

June 2005

Hylas who? - A response

by Daniel Mark Epstein

Daniel Mark Epstein replies.

Many thanks to the poet and philosopher John Koethe for applying Ockham's razor to the Hylas reference in Wilbur's poem, and reminding us that Berkeley's "Three Dialogues" is the likely source of the allusion. I went far afield in linking the image to the Argonautica, without, I think, doing violence to Wilbur's theme. I maintain that by the end of the poem Wilbur has identified with Hylas' tree, fearing that he "Will fall to nothing and without a sound." I do wonder if Berkeley named Hylas for that bold Argonaut who is the symbol of impartial investigation.

Daniel Mark Epstein wrote the libretto for the opera Jefferson and Poe, with music by Damon Ferrante.


more from this author

This article originally appeared in The New Criterion, Volume 23 June 2005, on page 98

Copyright © 2008 The New Criterion | www.newcriterion.com

http://www.newcriterion.com/articles.cfm/hylas-who-2-1344
rate this article for your user profile

E-mail to friend

Subscriber login

The New Criterion

The New Criterion is now optimized for Mobile Devices

Already a print subscriber? click for online access

login

Remember:

You might also enjoy

By the author

Who cares about Robert E. Lee?

by Daniel Mark Epstein

On Elizabeth Brown Pryor's new look at the Confederate general.

The metaphysics of Richard Wilbur

by Daniel Mark Epstein

Does society appreciate one of its finest metaphysical poets?

Most popular

view more >

download
first delivery

New from The New Criterion:
40 page special issue
on our conference

‘Free speech in
an age of Jihad’

Events

October 22 2008

GALA EVENT: The New Criterion Benefit Art Auction


January 25 2009

TRAVEL EVENT: The New Criterion Cruise


Webcasts

The Milt Rosenberg Show: Free Speech in an age of Jihad
Roger Kimball, David Yezzi, and James Panero discuss the New Criterion special pamphlet "Free Speech in an Age of Jihad." From the Milt Rosenberg Show, WGN. Recorded live in the Chicago studios 8/14/2008.


Roger Kimball on liberalism's response to Islam
From an evening with the Illinois chapter of the Friends of The New Criterion. Recorded on 8/16/2008.


Encounter Books at 10, an interview with Roger Simon