America’s leading review of the arts and intellectual life
The Amis country
by David Yezzi
On the poetry of Kingsley Amis.
was right!Support The
First of all: that’s Kingsley not Martin, the author of Lucky Jim not Yellow Dog, which may strike some readers as atavistic (and even a little quaint), given how fully Amis the Second has deposed Amis the First in the literary press. Still, Zachary Leader’s new biography, The Life of Kingsley Amis, reviewed in these pages last month by Mark Steyn, provides a welcome occasion to look again at the elder Amis’s splendid, varied, and enduring contribution to letters. Even a quick review of Amis’s work reveals him as a dab hand in several genres—from essays, memoirs, novels, and poems to his raucous correspondence, a hefty volume of which Leader edited in 2000.
Lucky Jim is simply one of the funniest (and best) books of the last hundred years, and it is no surprise that Amis the novelist has assumed pride of place in any reconsideration of his work. But what of the other Amises—including Amis the anthologist (The New Oxford Book of Light Verse, The Faber Popular Reciter), Amis the gastronome (On Drink), and Amis the critic (Rudyard Kipling and His World)? Of these, perhaps it is Amis the poet who is now most often neglected. He produced only a few slim volumes and wrote the sort of poems that have long fallen out of fashion: bare-knuckled, witty, light but never “lite,” outward-looking instead of inward-gazing—a kind of red-blooded vers de société that is in a league with E. A. Robinson’s poignant cameos and “Eros Turannos”; with Auden’s “Miss Gee,” “On the Circuit,” and “Who’s Who”; and with the poems of his friends and fellow Movement poets Robert Conquest and Philip Larkin. As Clive James wrote recently in The Times Literary Supplement: if Philip Larkin had never written, Amis’s “capacity to dramatize inner conflict and make it vivid through mastery of phrase and rhythm, would have made him … a contender for the title of the most accomplished and least self-satisfied poet of his generation.”
Larkin looms large in any reading of Amis’s poems. The two were lifelong friends, beginning with their days at St. John’s College, Oxford, in the early 1940s: Both were jazz enthusiasts, both suspicious of bogus poeticizing, both weary of the obfuscations of modernism. Amis, of course, greatly revered his friend’s poems and understood their lasting importance. When in the late 1970s Amis’s son Martin lent his father’s copy of The Less Deceived to a girlfriend, Larkin sent along a replacement. Kingsley acknowledged the gift in a letter from 1979, the same year his collected poems appeared:
Amis’s and Larkin’s shared allergy to sleeve-worn sentiment and pointless ornamentation led them to favor irony and the sober reflections of the plainspoken (and less-deceived) observer. Despite such affinities, however, a fundamental difference in tone distinguishes one poet’s work from the other’s. Where Larkin’s poems respond to life’s disappointments with a biting melancholy, Amis’s are slashingly satiric. Like the speaker of his poem “A Chromatic Passing-Note,” Amis replied to the ways in which experience inevitably falls short of the ideal with “a snarl of disappointment.”
Larkin, in the end, was the greater poet, as even Amis seems to have realized. Larkin was able to approach more nearly the flame of sentiment without getting singed. Having said that, Larkin (by choice or disposition) never matches the fierce note that Amis strikes so affectingly in poems such as “Nothing to Fear” (“I seem to sense/ A different style of caller at my back/ As cold as ice, but just as set on me”) and in his squalid portrait of the Welsh traveling salesman Dai Evans from “The Evans Country” sequence:
Amis’s poems rush headlong into the messiness of life, where Larkin’s tread with a more measured gait. Amis once remarked to the novelist John Mortimer that Larkin “was unlike us. He never threw himself at life. Marriage, adultery, all that sort of thing. He avoided all that.” Larkin’s moral tone recalls someone who has resisted the ersatz glamour of temptation and taken wistful solace in the fact that no eggs were broken. Amis’s moral tone suggests the penitent—someone who has made many omelettes with eggs filched from nearby farms and, tormented, turned himself in. For Larkin, deprivation, then, really was (in his famous phrase) what daffodils were for Wordsworth, which is to say he discovered in deprivation a certain nobility and even beauty. Deprivation for Amis, by contrast, generated something akin to anger—a frustration with the human condition and in particular with the agonies of the male libido—which fueled his brutal send-ups.
Both poets could be scathingly funny, in person and in print, but the tenor of Amis’s humor, in the poems at least, could rarely be mistaken for Larkin’s. Amis underscores the difference in his funeral address for Larkin in December 1985, in which he quotes his friend as saying:
Could one, I wonder, say the same for Amis? Venom becomes in his poems a kind of life’s blood, coursing through them the way it courses through the more scathing passages in his fiction. Take for instance this skewering of the insufferable Bertrand Welsh, whom Jim Dixon encounters in a decidedly unlucky moment:
Not even Jim himself, the hero of the novel, escapes such hilarious, ruthless treatment.
Amis’s poems, like his novels, unsparingly lay bare his characters’ foibles. “A Song of Experience” unfolds in a pub—a setting close to Amis’s heart—and features an anonymous traveling salesman, a forerunner to Dai Evans. The proceedings begin jovially enough, then take a sinister turn:
Amis’s sordid portrait ends not in any alcohol-soaked glorification of this predatory creep and his conquests but with a chilling glimpse of his banality:
Amis tells Michael Barber in his Paris Review interview from 1975 that experimental writing, which he loathed, is “usually thought of as entirely to do with style and intelligibility. But there are other forms. I mean after all, can’t one have experiments in mixing farce and horror, comedy and seriousness … ?” “A Song of Experience” combines precisely these elements.
Amis’s mode is satire not confession, self-scrutiny not self-expression. As Paul Fussell writes in The Anti-Egotist: Kingsley Amis, Man of Letters, Amis sees the sometimes vile opinions of his central characters as being both his and not his, each character becoming not so much a version of the author as a conduit of self-criticism. “By projecting himself into an entity that is part of himself and yet not himself,” Amis writes, the novelist (or poet) “may be able to see more clearly, and judge more harshly, his own weaknesses and follies.”
When Amis was invited to edit The New Oxford Book of Light Verse (1978), Larkin was excited for him. Larkin, whose Oxford Book of Twentieth-Century English Verse (1973) had challenged the modernist leanings of Yeats’s Oxford Book of Modern Verse (1936), quipped to a colleague that the two of them would stamp their taste on the age in the end. Amis, in his introduction to the volume, was not as optimistic about the fortunes of light verse, which in the 1970s ranged from “political ephemera” to “exercises in the styles of the dead or the aging, for the most part in competitions in weekly journals; and limericks,” adding that he could not “see the situation improving much.” Far from improving, it has fallen off precipitously, leaving Amis’s poems to moulder in his own brilliant and ill-fated anthology.
Earlier in his introduction, Amis discusses vers de société in a way that recalls his own poems. He defines it as
Amis’s style is always perspicuous but not always what I would call bright. In fact, he can be relentlessly and hilariously gloomy, both about man’s nature and about his surroundings, as in “Lovely,” in which an old flame figures:
A similar sour irony marks the poem’s counterpart, “Shitty,” which appears on a facing page in Collected Poems 1944–1979:
Not surprisingly for someone who was so uproariously alive—whether stumbling drunk down the steps of the Garrick or suffering the hangover of another romantic indiscretion—Amis was extremely fearful of losing his ability in old age to drink and laugh and be with friends:
Some folks like Morrison are fortunate, retaining their faculties to the end; others like Weatherby and Hooper (and, finally, like Amis himself) are not so lucky:
Less angry, more circumspect, is this late untitled poem about the misery of last things, which begins:
This poem appeared in The Times Literary Supplement in May 2004. If, as Leader suggests, it is reminiscent of Larkin’s “Aubade,” which appeared in the TLS in 1977, it is because in it Amis moves away from persona and toward a lyric voice that, as in much of Larkin, one associates more nearly with the poet himself. Leader calls the poem (which, as the missing title suggests, may well be unfinished) Amis’s “ne plus ultra.” It is a fine and moving poem, but it is the sort of poem that, as Amis wrote in his letter on The Less Deceived, Larkin does “better than me.” Pure Amis is something grittier—bawdy and tragic, unflinching and unapologetic, culpable and morally acute, and teeming with an excess of life.
This article originally appeared in The New Criterion, Volume 25 April 2007, on page 32
Copyright © 2014 The New Criterion | www.newcriterion.comhttp://www.newcriterion.com/articles.cfm/The-Amis-country-3128
E-mail to friend
by David Yezzi
On "Vasily Kandinsky: From Blaue Reiter to the Bauhaus, 1910–1925” at the Neue Galerie, New York, NY.
by David Yezzi
Poetry has become sterile, but we can still find realism, humor, and intensity in the satiric impulse.
Uncovering the media lies that continue to shape the history of JFK's assassination
by Ben Downing
During World War II, Crete had a profound impact on several writers, including Patrick Leigh Fermor
by Marco Grassi
In search of the story of Piero della Francesca, the forgotten hero of the Early Renaissance
March 11 2014
Friends and Young Friends Event: Book Launch Party with Roger Scruton
March 25 2014
Friends and Young Friends Event: A conference on "Preserving an Open Society in a Perilous World"
April 01 2014
Friends and Young Friends Event: Piano Recital with Simone Dinnerstein
Introduction to The Kennedy Phenomenon
The Kennedy Phenomenon: "Watching the Kennedy Train-Wreck"
The Kennedy Phenomenon: "The Many Misjudgments of Richard Hofstadter"