The New Criterion
(Mobile Version)

The Media

October 2001

Bring back the duel!

by James Bowman

As is well known, members of Parliaments with rules derived from those of the mother of Parliaments are forbidden from using the word “liar” or “lie” to refer to other members or their remarks. You can see why this rule is a necessary one. The charge that someone is lacking in good faith poisons the wells of debate in a system that is founded on debate. It invites a retort in kind which at once drains the system of substance and renders the parliamentary process trivial. The deliberations of our own dear legislature have been trivialized and drained of substance for other reasons, however, which unhappy fact throws most if not all of our substantive political debate into the press—where charges of lying made by political adversaries against each other now seem to have become almost routine.

Of course, it is easy to lose one’s head in the heat of political strife, but what are we to think of those who, with every opp ...

This article is available to subscribers and for individual purchase

Log in

James Bowman is the author of Honor: A History (Encounter Books) and Media Madness: The Corruption of Our Political Culture, also published by Encounter (2008)
more from this author


This article originally appeared in The New Criterion, Volume 20 October 2001, on page 58
Copyright © 2012 The New Criterion | www.newcriterion.com


E-mail to friend(s)